Since I hear a lot about the Goodreads Choice Awards, where books win with vote totals in the 40-60K range, I promised to look at the winners from last year. Because these are popular books, it took a while to wait through the queue at the library, but finally, here they are:
Blake Couch’s novel won the Goodreads Choice Award for Best Science Fiction book with 41,261 votes. Crouch is a New York Times Bestselling author and has several other books available, starting from about 2010. The winning novel was published by Crown in June of 2019, and runs 324 pages. This review contains spoilers.
Barry Sutton is a police detective in New York City. He and his ex, Julia, lost their daughter Meghan in a car accident when she was 16. When a woman jumps from a highrise, Barry begins trying to investigate False Memory Syndrome, an illness where people think they’ve lived another life. He interviews sufferers and finally blunders into the answer. Helena Smith, a brilliant researcher, has invented a way to send people back into memory; however, use of her method resets the timeline for everyone. Although Helena tries to keep her discovery secret, it becomes a target for everyone from commercial interests, to the CIA, to foreign governments. The schematics are finally published on Wikileaks, and reality starts to crumble. Is there any way Barry and Helena can stop spread of the technology and stabilize reality again?
On the positive side, this is a story about 1) the dangers of technology and 2) a possible do-over for your life, a way to correct all those mistakes that you wish you’d never made, to save your children from harm, or to connect in the kind of relationships that will last. Couch spends some time on the relationships, where the characters try to make things better for each other, which is probably what readers like about it. However, the book is mainly about the damage to reality the resets do, as they shift the characters into different timelines. False Memory Syndrome eventually gives way to the apocalypse, complete with horrific details.
On the not so positive side, there’s a giant hole in the science, and I somehow didn’t really believe in the characters or the settings. Helena’s research produces a device called a “chair” that will record a memory and reinject it later. (Note: This isn’t SF. It’s already accomplished in the real world.) Slade, the man who provides her funding, produces a sensory deprivation chamber and an ugly procedure for killing people inside it and then injecting the recorded memory, which causes a branch in reality so the dead person wakes at the memory point in a different timeline. This isn’t an accident; it works reliably all the time. Other chairs and chambers built from the same schematics also work reliably. Couch discusses a jumble of theory about arrows of time and tiny wormholes, but none of this explains why the equipment works. Next, the characters feel like cardboard cutouts that Couch moves through the story. Sutton is described as a police detective, but he doesn’t think like a detective, act like a detective or work on police business in NYC. In some timelines, he shows amazing flexibility in picking up a second career as a scientist. Helena is described as a brilliant researcher, but she doesn’t act the part, either. After umpteen resets where she tries to fix things, it’s Sutton with his police-issue Glock who produces a solution.
I wasn’t really taken with this, but it’s clearly a popular favorite.
Three stars.
Recent Comments