This Nebula finalist is a fantasy novella published by The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction. It ended up with 11 recommendations on the Nebula Recommended Reading List.

Greg lives in a small Massachusetts town and considers himself a liar. This means that he can lie to things like broken rakes and convince them they aren’t broken. Pastor Julie can’t get him on the phone, so she comes to the house to ask him to step in as caretaker of the local cemetery. He agrees, but goes to talk to Joe, the last caretaker, whose back has gone out. Joe tells him there’s an accidental death of a young person every November 5. Concerned, Greg checks the records and finds this is true. He ties this to the crash of a World War II plane and a possible ghost. Can he and Pastor Julie deal with it?

I saw this described somewhere as a fantasy written by Garrison Keeler. That pretty much outlines the style. It’s very laid back and written in mystery format as Greg investigates and tracks down the threat to local youths while striving to bake the perfect apple pie. Mysteries normally have about three major plot twists, and this builds up nicely with a major twist about mid way, but it’s missing the expected one at the end, so ends up fairly anticlimactic. Murphy achieves great characterization of the narrator—I was involved and getting really concerned about Greg. The other characters are well-drawn, too, and the author injects an element of sadness about Greg’s brother, who turns out to have been one of the victim.

Four stars.

Advertisements